My friend Ryan, aka Meanie from Goonie’s World, recently pointed me toward a website called AnyDice, and we’ve been having a little fun playing around with it. It’s a fascinating little tool for examining dice probabilities, and I got to thinking about the way we use dice in roleplaying games. When you roll multiple dice and add them together (3d6, for example), the results will tend to form a curve, meaning the middle numbers are considerably more likely to come up than the extremes. Roll a single die (a d20, for example), and there is no curve. Every possible result has exactly the same chance of occurring. Of course, this is spelled out by Gygax in the opening pages of the 1979 Dungeon Masters Guide, so I’ve theoretically known this since adolescence (it was the basis of the AD&D vs. GURPS arguments in high school). But “seeing” the math at AnyDice brought this back to me in a fresh way.
I started wondering about its implications for game design. Not just game mechanics, but the stories those mechanics will help tell. Rolling 3d6 (or any multiples) produces a game world in which ordinary results are, well, ordinary. Exceptional results are possible, but increasingly unlikely the more exceptional they are. Rolling a single d20 (or any single die) produces something quite different. Every result is equally likely, whether it's a critical success, a critical failure, or something in between. Luck has a much larger role to play, and the extraordinary is always just as likely as the ordinary. Neither approach is necessarily better, but they certainly produce different outcomes, which produces different expectations about how the game will go.
D&D (or almost any riff on it) offers an example of both approaches working together. We generate ability scores using 3d6, which gives us bell-shaped mostly ordinary people, with exceptional individuals being relatively uncommon. Then we turn around and use a d20 for attack rolls, where every result is equally likely. Our characters might have fairly predictable ability scores, but their fortunes in the “dungeon” are definitely not predictable. Was that a deliberate combination? Would a game built entirely around only one approach feel substantially different? What happens when we introduce modifiers into these different probabilities? A “+1” doesn't necessarily have the same practical effect in both systems. At least, I don’t think so.
I don’t know that I have any conclusions, but it’s interesting to think about dice as more than just random number generators. The dice we choose help determine the “shape of randomness” in the game, and that shape influences the kinds of things that happen, how often they happen, and what players think will happen. I think that’s something worth paying a little more attention to.
No comments:
Post a Comment